Arguments For and Against the Lemon Test: A Balanced Perspective

📚 Quick Study Guide

📜
• The Lemon Test: Established in *Lemon v. Kurtzman* (1971), it determines if a law violates the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment.
⚖️
• Three Prongs:
  ✔️
  • Secular Purpose: The law must have a legitimate, non-religious purpose.
  ✔️
  • Neutral Effect: The primary effect must neither advance nor inhibit religion.
  ✔️
  • No Excessive Entanglement: The law must not foster excessive government entanglement with religion.
🏛️
• Arguments For: Upholds separation of church and state, prevents government endorsement of religion, and protects religious minorities.
⛔
• Arguments Against: Seen as overly strict, difficult to apply, and potentially hostile to religion. Some argue for alternative tests like coercion or endorsement tests.

Practice Quiz

1. Which Supreme Court case established the Lemon Test?
   1. A. *Engel v. Vitale*
   2. B. *Abington School District v. Schempp*
   3. C. *Lemon v. Kurtzman*
   4. D. *Wallace v. Jaffree*
2. What is the first prong of the Lemon Test?
   1. A. The law must not establish a state religion.
   2. B. The law must have a secular purpose.
   3. C. The law must not inhibit religion.
   4. D. The law must be popular.
3. According to the Lemon Test, what should the primary effect of the law be?
   1. A. To advance religion.
   2. B. To inhibit religion.
   3. C. To neither advance nor inhibit religion.
   4. D. To promote government entanglement with religion.
4. What is the 'excessive entanglement' aspect of the Lemon Test concerned with?
   1. A. Too much government spending on religious activities.
   2. B. Too much religious influence on government policies.
   3. C. The degree of interaction between government and religious institutions.
   4. D. The popularity of religious practices.
5. Which of the following is an argument in favor of the Lemon Test?
   1. A. It promotes religious expression in public schools.
   2. B. It prevents government endorsement of religion.
   3. C. It encourages government funding of religious institutions.
   4. D. It simplifies the application of the Establishment Clause.
6. What is a common criticism of the Lemon Test?
   1. A. It is too lenient on religious activities.
   2. B. It is overly strict and difficult to apply.
   3. C. It promotes government entanglement with religion.
   4. D. It is rarely used by the Supreme Court.
7. Which alternative test is sometimes proposed instead of the Lemon Test?
   1. A. The Rational Basis Test
   2. B. The Strict Scrutiny Test
   3. C. The Coercion Test
   4. D. The Intermediate Scrutiny Test